Overcoming therapist isolation through Berne and TA practice

Overcoming therapist isolation through Berne and TA practice

Not alone in the room: A dialogue with Eric Berne

A collaborative case study reveals how shared vulnerability aids family work.
Alexandra
Svitenko
Svetlana
Seguin
Costume party (1 of 14). Creator: Not specified. Contributor: UCSF Archives and Special Collections. Date Created and/or Issued: 1959-08. Publication Information: Digital resource published by the Regents of the University of California. Contributing Institution: UC San Francisco, Library, Special Collections. Collection: Berne (Eric L.) Collections. Rights Holder and Contact: Regents of the University of California. Description: Scope/Content: One of a series of images of a costume party (hosted by Eric Berne?) in August, 1959. Scope/Content: See additional related photographs Eric L. Berne Papers, 1939-1973, MSS 82-0, box 2, folder 10. Format: 3 1/2" x 2 1/2". Photograph.

“All real living is meeting.” — Martin Buber (1923/1937)

Psychotherapy is often a solitary profession. We spend hours behind closed doors, holding our clients’ pain, our doubts and our own reactions — alone. Even within a professional community, in the moment of the session, the therapist remains by themselves. This isolation is rarely discussed, though it is well known (McWilliams, 2004; Yalom, 2002).

Eric Berne described autonomy not only as awareness and spontaneity, but also as the capacity for intimacy (Berne, 1961). This invites a different view of professional independence — not as isolation, but as something that can emerge in dialogue. His Tuesday night seminars were spaces where ideas grew through conversation, suggesting that dialogue has always been at the heart of transactional analysis.

We worked within the same family system, though not in traditional co-therapy. One of us worked with the mother, while the other worked with the child and met regularly with both parents. We were in different places and never observed each other’s sessions. Yet, over time, a dialogue began to emerge between us.

Early on, both of us experienced strong countertransference reactions. The child therapist felt her work was less significant. The adult therapist felt the opposite — that the child therapist held more valuable knowledge. Each of us felt “not OK” next to a “more significant other.”

To speak about this required courage. It meant allowing ourselves to be seen not only in competence, but also in doubt.

Gradually, it became clear that this dynamic did not belong only to us, but reflected the family. The mother focused entirely on the child’s behavior, leaving no space for herself. The father remained distant, and the child felt unseen. Across the system, the same pattern repeated: “The other is more important than me.”

A few months into the work, tension appeared between us — irritation and anger without a clear source. We chose not to act it out, but to stay with it. Over time, it became clear that this anger did not belong to us personally. It reflected what could not be expressed in the family.

By staying in dialogue and holding this tension, something began to change. The mother found the energy to express anger and return to work. The child became more able to say “no” and protect her boundaries.

In one of her stories, a kitten was trapped in a labyrinth, the walls closing in. It called for help. Its friends could not enter, but they kept calling: “We are here. Follow our voice.” When the kitten heard them, the walls crumbled like sand.

We began to see that the family’s pattern — “I’m not OK, You’re OK” (Ernst, 1971) — was also present between us. By reflecting on it instead of repeating it, a different space emerged. The parents began to see that difficulties did not belong to one person alone, but arose in interaction. Their dialogue became more alive and supportive.

As we allowed our own vulnerability, warmth and respect grew between us. In this shared space, it became possible to think together, to feel and to remain in contact without diminishing each other. This felt like movement toward autonomy in Berne’s sense — awareness, spontaneity and intimacy.

Our experience is not a finished model. Yet we see that when therapists remain in dialogue — holding difference, uncertainty and vulnerability — something new can emerge.

In a profession marked by solitude, this opens another way of being present — one in which the therapist is no longer alone in the room, but part of an ongoing dialogue — one that, in a sense, continues with Eric Berne.

Perhaps this is what he meant when he described autonomy as the capacity for intimacy. And perhaps this is what Buber (1923/1937) meant: “All real living is meeting.”

Footnotes

References

Berne, E. (1961). Transactional analysis in psychotherapy. Grove Press.

Buber, M. (1937). I and thou (R. G. Smith, Trans.). T. & T. Clark. (Original work published 1923)

Ernst, F. H. (1971). The OK corral: The grid for get-on-with. Transactional Analysis Journal, 1(4), 33–42.

McWilliams, N. (2004). Psychoanalytic psychotherapy. Guilford Press.

Yalom, I. D. (2002). The gift of therapy. HarperCollins.

Cite this article (APA 7)

Loading citation…

Overcoming therapist isolation through Berne and TA practice
May 2026
56
5
new-eata-and-itaa-collaboration-focuses-on-decolonizing-ta
New EATA and ITAA collaboration focuses on decolonizing TA
july-2026
The Script Newsroom
iboc-concludes-second-online-tew-of-2026-for-global-analysts
IBOC concludes second online TEW of 2026 for global analysts
july-2026
Marina Rajan Joseph
the-evolution-of-redecision-therapy-beyond-the-goulding-era
The evolution of redecision therapy beyond the Goulding era
july-2026
Tony White
psychotherapy-research-bias-examined-in-free-taj-article
Psychotherapy research bias examined in free TAJ article
july-2026
Robin Fryer
itaa-board-nominations-open-for-professional-standards-director
ITAA board nominations open for professional standards director
july-2026
The Script Newsroom
itaa-deia-task-force-shares-updates-on-inclusive-ta-training
ITAA DEIA Task Force shares updates on inclusive TA training
july-2026
Alva Ramírez Villatoro
human-os-marks-one-year-of-collaborative-developmental-ta
Human OS marks one year of collaborative developmental TA
july-2026
Suriyaprakash C
new-taj-special-issue-explores-social-sciences-research-topics
New TAJ special issue explores social sciences research topics
july-2026
Robin Fryer
the-script-is-taking-a-three-month-pause-for-system-upgrades
The Script is taking a three-month pause for system upgrades
july-2026
Marguerite Sacco
psychological-games-reveal-a-new-pattern-of-therapy-sabotage
Psychological games reveal a new pattern of therapy sabotage
july-2026
Tatiana Panova
social-media-and-teens-face-the-influencer-economy-crisis
Social media and teens face the influencer economy crisis
july-2026
Werner Himmelbauer
securing-the-future-of-ta-psychotherapy-through-research
Securing the future of TA psychotherapy through research
july-2026
Roland Johnsson
spain-drops-ta-from-its-therapy-lacking-empirical-support-list
Spain drops TA from its therapy lacking empirical support list
july-2026
José Manuel Martínez Rodríguez
how-film-therapy-bridges-the-gap-in-modern-psychotherapy
How film therapy bridges the gap in modern psychotherapy
july-2026
Anoushka Beazley
itaa-welcomes-18-members-from-11-nations-in-june-expansion
ITAA welcomes 18 members from 11 nations in June expansion
july-2026
The Script Newsroom
ethical-guidelines-for-the-itaa-member-badge-and-logo-use
Ethical guidelines for the ITAA member badge and logo use
july-2026
Michelle Colla Thomé
child-therapy-why-shared-observation-promotes-genuine-healing
Watching together: What Berne taught me about children
july-2026
Svetlana Seguin
saata-2027-event-bengaluru-to-host-multi-level-learning
SAATA 2027 event: Bengaluru to host multi-level learning
june-2026
Sudha Thimmaiah
joel-vos-wins-2026-itaa-research-award-for-psychotherapy
Joel Vos wins 2026 ITAA Research Award for psychotherapy
june-2026
Moniek Thunnissen
requesting-a-transactional-analysis-journal-2025-replacement
Requesting a Transactional Analysis Journal 2025 replacement
june-2026
Robin Fryer
rosa-krausz-groundbreaking-organizational-scholar-dies-at-93
Rosa Krausz, groundbreaking organizational scholar, dies at 93
june-2026
The Script Newsroom
first-2026-iboc-online-tew-prepares-new-global-educators
First 2026 IBOC online TEW prepares new global educators
june-2026
Marina Rajan Joseph
sign-up-as-an-examiner-or-volunteer-for-iboc-2026-exams
Sign up as an examiner or volunteer for IBOC 2026 exams
june-2026
2027-eric-berne-memorial-award-nominations-are-now-open
2027 Eric Berne Memorial Award nominations are now open
june-2026
The Script Newsroom
edward-t-novak-receives-the-2026-eric-berne-memorial-award
Edward T. Novak receives the 2026 Eric Berne Memorial Award
june-2026
A. Sari van Poelje
itaa-it-committee-opens-applications-for-technical-members
ITAA IT committee opens applications for technical members
june-2026
Sumedh Singh
ecocentric-perspective-a-nature-based-approach-to-trauma
Ecocentric perspective: A nature-based approach to trauma
june-2026
Cinzia Chiesa
transactional-analysis-in-psychotherapy-needs-a-new-global-body
Transactional analysis in psychotherapy needs a new global body
june-2026
Thomas Ohlsson
ethical-disclosure-a-commitment-to-transparency
Ethical disclosure: A commitment to transparency
june-2026
Michelle Colla Thomé
power-dynamics-in-therapy-and-the-illusion-of-decolonization
Power dynamics in therapy and the illusion of decolonization
june-2026
Nada Khader
itaa-membership-expands-as-27-professionals-join-in-may
ITAA membership expands as 27 professionals join in May
june-2026
The Script Newsroom
neuro-informed-ta-a-new-framework-for-neurodivergent-clients
Neuro-informed TA: A new framework for neurodivergent clients
june-2026
Nea Clark
bernes-transactional-analysis-takes-root-in-mainland-china
Berne's transactional analysis takes root in mainland China
may-2026
Lei Chen
what-psychologist-carol-solomon-learned-from-eric-berne
What psychologist Carol Solomon learned from Eric Berne
may-2026
Pamela Levin
karpman-recalls-berne-and-the-origins-of-transactional-analysis
Karpman recalls Berne and the origins of transactional analysis
may-2026
being-in-the-room-eric-berne-and-the-decision-that-changes-everything
Being in the room: Eric Berne and the decision that changes everything
may-2026
Lyn Wall
why-berne-considered-sexuality-a-fundamental-aspect-of-ta
Why Berne considered sexuality a fundamental aspect of TA
may-2026
Alessandra Braga
how-eric-berne-used-ta-to-build-a-psychology-of-belonging
How Eric Berne used TA to build a psychology of belonging
may-2026
Liliia Lukianova
eric-bernes-birthday-why-games-people-play-still-matters
Eric Berne's birthday: Why "Games People Play" still matters
may-2026
Mayya Lutay
open-letter-51-years-of-transactional-analysis-at-itaa
Open letter: 51 years of transactional analysis at ITAA
may-2026
Stephen E. Cosgrove
itaa-welcomes-30-new-members-from-15-countries-in-april
ITAA welcomes 30 new members from 15 countries in April
may-2026
The Script Newsroom
pamela-levin-reflects-on-eric-berne-and-his-therapy-legacy
Pamela Levin reflects on Eric Berne and his therapy legacy
may-2026
Vinícius Sgarbe
how-eric-berne-shaped-a-journey-into-transactional-analysis
How Eric Berne shaped a journey into transactional analysis
may-2026
Roksana Yashchuk
what-eric-berne-represents-to-me-as-a-young-psychotherapist
What Eric Berne represents to me as a young psychotherapist
may-2026
Manuel Luciani
treating-war-trauma-what-eric-bernes-1945-texts-teach-us
Treating war trauma: What Eric Berne’s 1945 texts teach us
may-2026
Hanna Yavorska
overcoming-therapist-isolation-through-berne-and-ta-practice
Overcoming therapist isolation through Berne and TA practice
may-2026
the-capacity-for-ethical-dialogue-in-modern-psychotherapy
The capacity for ethical dialogue in modern psychotherapy
may-2026
Sushma Ramachandran
eric-berne-in-the-age-of-trauma-from-games-to-survival-strategies
Eric Berne in the age of trauma: From games to survival strategies
may-2026
Prof. Ashok Riehm
nataa-2026-retreat-explores-transactional-analysis-origins
NATAA 2026 retreat explores transactional analysis origins
april-2026
Lucy Freedman
itaa-membership-global-network-welcomes-31-in-march-2026
ITAA membership: Global network welcomes 31 in March 2026
april-2026
The Script Newsroom
addressing-metoo-and-power-abuse-in-clinical-psychology
Addressing #MeToo and power abuse in clinical psychology
april-2026
Lena Kornyeyeva
march-iboc-exams-successfully-certify-transactional-analysts
March IBOC exams successfully certify transactional analysts
april-2026
free-article-by-william-cornell-reviews-ai-in-psychotherapy
Free article by William Cornell reviews AI in psychotherapy
april-2026
Robin Fryer
global-conflict-how-daily-habits-shape-systemic-oppression
Global conflict: How daily habits shape systemic oppression
april-2026
Julia Pool
poetry-in-psychotherapy-healing-through-the-framework-of-ta
Poetry in psychotherapy: Healing through the framework of TA
april-2026
Svetlana Seguin
what-is-your-evolving-relationship-with-ethics-in-practice
What is your evolving relationship with ethics in practice?
april-2026
Alex van Oostveen
2026-itaa-awards-honor-thorsten-geck-and-sailaja-manacha
2026 ITAA awards honor Thorsten Geck and Sailaja Manacha
march-2026
The Script Newsroom
perinatal-mental-health-study-examines-therapy-approaches
Perinatal mental health study examines therapy approaches
march-2026
Emma Haynes
first-lontac-gathering-breaks-hierarchies-in-psychotherapy
First LonTAC gathering breaks hierarchies in psychotherapy
march-2026
Sam Carbon
ta-meeting-unites-participants-from-6-countries-in-antigua
TA meeting unites participants from 6 countries in Antigua
march-2026
Piotr Jusik
itaa-welcomes-34-new-members-amid-global-february-growth
ITAA welcomes 34 new members amid global February growth
march-2026
The Script Newsroom
holding-coherence-amid-fragmentation-insights-from-sec-webinar
Holding coherence amid fragmentation: Insights from SEC webinar
march-2026
Luca Fornari
ukrainian-transactional-analysis-conference-explores-autonomy
Ukrainian transactional analysis conference explores autonomy
march-2026
Roksana Yashchuk
how-transactional-analysis-is-being-reframed-for-children-today
How transactional analysis is being reframed for children today
march-2026
Vinícius Sgarbe
ta-ai-working-group-seeks-input-to-shape-future-exam-policies
TA AI Working group seeks input to shape future exam policies
march-2026
James Longwell
boards-announce-new-rules-and-limits-for-online-oral-exams
Boards announce new rules and limits for online oral exams
march-2026
transactional-analysis-journal-calls-for-papers-on-physis-in-action
Transactional Analysis Journal calls for papers on ‘physis in action’
march-2026
how-a-classic-ethical-dilemma-teaches-moral-reasoning
How a classic ethical dilemma teaches moral reasoning
march-2026
Jan Grant
iboc-announces-live-exam-dates-for-new-zealand-and-uk
IBOC announces live exam dates for New Zealand and UK
february-2026
Nicole Lenner
taj-announces-new-theme-issue-on-parenthood-and-the-perinatal
TAJ announces new theme issue on parenthood and the perinatal
february-2026
TAJ Newsroom
readers-can-now-access-a-key-article-on-ai-in-ta-for-free
Readers can now access a key article on AI in TA for free
february-2026
TAJ Newsroom
everyday-changes-reshape-identity-through-the-process-of-grief
Everyday changes reshape identity through the process of grief
february-2026
Sasha Mkhitaryan
respected-tsta-diane-salters-retires-after-distinguished-career
Respected TSTA Diane Salters retires after distinguished career
february-2026
The Script Newsroom
new-taj-issue-explores-impact-of-ai-and-digital-life-on-therapy
New TAJ issue explores impact of AI and digital life on therapy
february-2026
TAJ Newsroom
a-tribute-to-robin-fryer-the-force-and-spirit-of-the-script
A tribute to Robin Fryer, 'the force and spirit' of The Script
february-2026
William Cornell
emotions-are-integral-to-ethical-reasoning-and-moral-judgment
Emotions are integral to ethical reasoning and moral judgment
february-2026
John Evans
remembering-jenny-robinson-a-gentle-soul-with-fierce-resolve
Remembering Jenny Robinson, a 'gentle soul' with fierce resolve
february-2026
David Rawson
ukrainian-analysts-find-strength-in-ethics-during-four-years-of-war
Ukrainian analysts find strength in ethics during four years of war
february-2026
Hanna Yavorska
new-feminist-model-challenges-how-therapists-treat-gendered-trauma
New feminist model challenges how therapists treat gendered trauma
february-2026
Jazz Rehal
saata-hosts-26th-annual-learning-event-in-coastal-india
SAATA hosts 26th annual learning event in coastal India
february-2026
Rosemary Kurian
global-community-grows-with-diverse-new-voices-from-15-countries
Global community grows with diverse new voices from 15 countries
february-2026
The Script Newsroom
jenny-robinson-leaves-legacy-of-safe-therapeutic-communities
Jenny Robinson leaves legacy of safe therapeutic communities
february-2026
Cholena Mountain
watch-for-your-2025-transactional-analysis-journal-in-the-mail
Watch for your 2025 Transactional Analysis Journal in the mail
february-2026
TAJ Newsroom
global-workshop-unites-new-trainers-from-kenya-to-croatia
Global workshop unites new trainers from Kenya to Croatia
january-2026
Marina Rajan Joseph
new-platform-integrates-author-content-with-member-interaction
New platform integrates author content with member interaction
january-2026
Vinícius Sgarbe
embodied-therapy-unlocks-early-script-material
Embodied therapy unlocks early script material
january-2026
Marie Eleonore Lind
analyst-develops-new-ta-concepts-from-certification
Analyst develops new TA concepts from certification
january-2026
Ashley Jack
research-links-inner-child-scripts-to-adult-physical-health-issues
Research links inner child scripts to adult physical health issues
january-2026
Pamela Levin
what-changes-what-endures-responsibility-beyond-here-and-now
What changes, what endures: Responsibility beyond the here and now
january-2026
Keiko Hoshino
to-speak-out-or-remain-silent-the-ethical-dilemma-facing-the-itaa
To speak out or remain silent: The ethical dilemma facing the ITAA
january-2026
Marguerite Sacco
itaa-committee-integrates-social-justice-into-core-ta-principles
ITAA committee integrates social justice into core TA principles
january-2026
Piotr Jusik
association-welcomes-62-new-members-in-recent-global-intakes
Association welcomes 62 new members in recent global intakes
january-2026
The Script Newsroom
answer-the-call-serve-our-community-as-general-secretary
Answer the call: Serve our community as general secretary
january-2026

Join the discussion

Comments are for members. Log in to read them and share your thoughts.