
“Something does not feel right. But I do not yet know whether it is an ethical issue.”
We may encounter such moments in a session, training, supervision or organizational meeting. Even when we cannot explain what is wrong, the atmosphere may feel different. Our bodies may tense, our emotions may shift, or another person’s silence or expression may attract our attention.
The unease does not necessarily indicate a problem in the other person. We may notice a mismatch between their words and facial expression and begin to consider how our own words or actions have affected them.
Ethical awareness does not always begin in words. In his early study of intuition, Berne (1949) described it as knowledge based on experience and acquired through sensory contact, although a person may not be able to explain exactly how they reached a conclusion. The body and emotions may respond before we find words for the experience; the Adult can then examine what those responses may mean. Hervey (2007) similarly suggested that noticing changes in our bodily state can help us recognize an ethical dilemma.
Intuition may contain accurate perception, but it may also be influenced by our personal history, anxiety, bias and cultural assumptions. Unease is therefore neither something to dismiss nor, by itself, a basis for judging that someone has acted unethically.
The “On Ethics” contributions in The Script have offered a range of perspectives on ethics. Among them, de Graaf and Grant (2021) emphasized inquiry rather than blame, while Abe (2023) reminded us that none of us is immune to ethical mistakes.
The revised 2024 Ethics Manual of the International Transactional Analysis Association (ITAA, 2024) continues this ethical dialogue and provides a process for responding to ethical concerns. Here, I propose one way of using the manual in practice by linking it with Julie Hay’s (1996) Steps to Success model.
Hay’s model consists of six stages: Situation, Significance, Solutions, Skills, Strategies and Success. Applied to ethical inquiry, it can help us move from an unclear feeling toward responsible action without reaching a conclusion too quickly.
Figure 1 presents this ethical application as a spiral. Unease opens the inquiry, and the six stages move inward toward Success as learning and change. The dotted return path shows that, if sabotage appears as we approach Success, we may need to reconsider the Situation. If the concern remains unresolved, the ITAA Phase 1 Form provides a separate route into the formal process.

Any of us can notice an ethical concern, and any of us can be the person whose conduct raises it. The following trainer-trainee situation is one example in which the power difference is relatively easy to see.
A trainer asks a trainee to take on a role that was not included in their contract. The trainee says yes, but their expression becomes tense, and they speak less during the rest of the meeting. Several days later, the trainer continues to feel uneasy about the interaction.
We do not yet need to conclude either that the trainee freely agreed or that the trainer misused power. We first identify observable information: What happened? What was said? What did the contract provide? What effects were observed? The inquiry must include not only the other person’s conduct but also our own: What did I do, and what did I fail to do?
Drawing on transactional analysis (TA) contracting (McGrath, 1994), culturally responsive ethical decision-making (Lee, 2022) and the systemic perspective of the revised ITAA Ethics Manual, I propose four practical lenses to support the Situation stage: Self, Contract, Relationship and System.
Figure 2 brings the four lenses together as a practical prompt for the Situation stage. They are not a diagnostic checklist; they invite us to widen the inquiry before deciding what the situation means.

Lee (2022) notes that, in cultural contexts emphasizing hierarchy and relational harmony, concerns may not be expressed directly. The trainee’s yes may have been an attempt to protect the relationship or their future evaluation. However, this is only one possibility. Rather than deciding what the response meant on the basis of cultural assumptions, we need to ask the trainee how they experienced the situation and what their yes meant to them.
We can now use the manual’s Grid for Ethical Assessment to consider the situation in relation to the ITAA’s five ethical principles: Respect, Empowerment, Protection, Responsibility and Commitment in relationship.
Rather than quickly labeling the situation, we ask who may have been affected, how they may have been affected, whether meaningful choice was available and which principles require attention.
At this stage, we do not immediately choose one answer. We explore a range of possible directions: further dialogue to understand the situation, acknowledging the impact, reviewing the contract or roles, stopping or changing the conduct, repairing the relationship, seeking supervision or third-party consultation, or using the ITAA ethics process. We also consider how each option may affect the people and systems involved.
When a concern is raised about us, explaining that we did not intend harm is not enough. The absence of harmful intent does not mean that the other person experienced no harmful impact. We first need to listen and consider what can be changed or repaired.
Direct dialogue can be valuable, but it is not always safe or appropriate. Where there is a significant power difference, where speaking directly may result in disadvantage, or where the concern involves serious harm or repeated conduct, consulting a third party or using the ITAA ethics process may need to come first.
Ethical action may require the skills needed to receive feedback, manage defensiveness, apologize, renew a contract, set a boundary or ask about cultural meaning.
Support may come from a supervisor, a trusted colleague, an interpreter, a mediator or the Ethics Committee. Whom can I consult, and how should I prepare? Seeking consultation is an important step in taking responsibility for my response.
Here, we select appropriate options and decide who will do what and when. For example, the trainer might first seek supervision and then offer the trainee a meeting, with the option of having a third person present. In the meeting, the trainer can acknowledge that the trainee’s freedom to refuse may not have been sufficiently clear and listen to the trainee’s experience. They can then discuss the way forward together and, where appropriate, record what was agreed and when it will be reviewed.
If the concern remains unresolved, or if direct dialogue is inappropriate or not feasible, the petitioner can follow the routes set out in Phase 1 and use the Phase 1 Form to submit the concern. The facts, ethical principles and options identified through these steps may help the petitioner prepare the form.
Success is not simply the point at which we decide whether to act. It involves identifying the desired outcome, moving toward it and sustaining the change.
Here, success does not mean proving that the trainer was right or requiring the trainee to accept an apology. It might mean that the trainee can express a choice without fearing disadvantage, that roles and authority are clarified, that responsibility is taken for the impact and that arrangements are made to reduce the likelihood of repetition.
As the dotted return path in Figure 1 indicates, Hay (2018) also describes how sabotage can arise as we move toward Success. The trainer may minimize the concern to protect their professional reputation. The trainee may say, “It is all right now,” because of anxiety about a future evaluation. The organization may treat a systemic concern as a private difficulty between two individuals.
When we notice such movements, we can return to the Situation stage. Using the four lenses again, we can ask whose fears, interests or vulnerabilities may be obstructing change. Ethical decision-making may require action, reflection and reconsideration.
The revised ITAA Ethics Manual is not only for those who want to raise a formal concern. It can also guide those who cannot yet explain their unease, those examining their own conduct and those seeking consultation or accountability.
Intuition may alert us. Unease may make us pause. Adult inquiry can help us decide how to act.
We can move from Situation toward Success, include ourselves in the inquiry and seek the support we need. When appropriate, the Phase 1 Form provides a route for a petitioner to submit a concern to the ITAA.
Being ethical does not mean always being right. It includes pausing, listening to feedback, accepting responsibility and working toward safer and more respectful relationships. In this way, Steps to Success connects Berne’s attention to intuition with the practical pathway in the revised manual.
The next time something does not feel right, with whom will you explore that intuitive unease, and how will you begin?
Abe, T. (2023). Being ethically minded: When and how do we think about ethical issues? The Script, 53(2), 14.
Berne, E. (1949). The nature of intuition. Psychiatric Quarterly, 23, 203–226. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01563116
de Graaf, A., & Grant, J. (2021). The times they are a-changin’, aren’t they? The Script, 51(7), 9–10.
Hay, J. (1996). Steps to success: Combining TA and NLP. INTAND Newsletter, 4(3), 6–8.
Hay, J. (2018). Psychological boundaries and psychological bridges: A categorisation and the application of transactional analysis concepts. International Journal of Transactional Analysis Research & Practice, 9(1), 52–81. https://doi.org/10.29044/v9i1p52
Hervey, L. W. (2007). Embodied ethical decision making. American Journal of Dance Therapy, 29(2), 91–108. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10465-007-9036-5
International Transactional Analysis Association. (2024, November 11). Code of ethics: Philosophy and guidelines for ethical practice.
Lee, I. (2022). Ethical decision-making in counseling clients with Asian cultural values. The Rehabilitation Professional, 30(3), 27–40.
McGrath, G. (1994). Ethics, boundaries, and contracts: Applying moral principles. Transactional Analysis Journal, 24(1), 6–14. https://doi.org/10.1177/036215379402400103
Cite this article (APA 7)
Loading citation…